Sirotablog

David Sirota is a political journalist and nationally syndicated newspaper columnist at Creators Syndicate. David writes about political corruption, globalization and working-class economic issues often ignored by both of America's political parties.

  • September 1, 2007 11:06 AM

    CAUGHT ON TAPE: GOP Advocates Letting Homes Burn Down In Face of Wildfires

    You want to see the real-world problems with right-wing extremism? Here's a good example of it from Big Sky Country. With Montana facing major wildfires, senior Montana Republican lawmaker John Sinrud - who heads the state House's appropriations committee - used a legislative hearing this week to attack Gov. Brian Schweitzer's (D) administration for - get ready for this - trying to prevent homes and buildings from being burnt down. At the hearing, he asks "Why not just let [buildings] burn?" Ah yes, what a refreshing dose of "compassionate" conservatism.

    You can listen to the audio yourself right here (h/t Left In the West):

    What makes this statement even more offensive is the back story. See the extended entry for what I'm talking about.

    The Helena Independent Record last week reported that Schweitzer is being forced to call an emergency legislative session (at a cost of $65,000 per day) in order to obtain more firefighting money because Republicans like Sinrud previously rejected his efforts to add that money to the budget - all while they advocated for massive tax cuts for out-of-state corporations. The Montana GOP has responded by writing letters to the editor claiming Schweitzer is lying, though the Great Falls Tribune editorial board debunks that claim entirely - showing that it is the GOP that is lying. Here's an excerpt:

    "Gov. Brian Schweitzer called Thursday to advocate on behalf of his appropriation request in the special legislative session he called for this Wednesday in Helena. He rightly disputed claims in a letter to the editor by Rep. Rick Ripley, R-Wolf Creek, that the governor had never requested $25 million for fires. The amount is in Schweitzer's original budget, and it was in a bill that was killed, on a party-line vote, by the Appropriations Committee on which Ripley sits. The session is needed, Schweitzer said, because 'we've got bills to pay' -- totaling about $34 million -- and the Legislature won't otherwise meet until 2009. 'I can't say to contractors, 'We're out of money, sorry.'" (emphasis NOT added - it was in the original editorial).

    So, to review. The Montana Republican Party is now on record A) Attacking Montana state government for trying to stop buildings and homes from being burnt down B) Rejecting money to better fund firefighting while pushing massive tax cuts for out-of-state corporations and C) Lying about rejecting money to better fund firefighting.

    I guess the best thing you could say about Sinrud after this is that at least he didn't use profanity, like his colleague Rep. Michael Lange (R) infamously did a few months ago. That said, most people will probably find his desire to see Montana homes and buildings burn down even more offensive than Lange's temper tantrum.

    This has been your daily example of right-wing extremism - and its destructive consequences.

Discussion

  • DA [TypeKey Profile Page] :

    Ya know that debate we hear so often that asks if our sexual preference is determined at birth or not? How about our political persuasion? Is it possible being a "Compassionate Conservative" is an accident of birth? A gene-pool thing, maybe? DNA? Sheez.

    Posted on September 1, 2007 2:16 PM
  • butte [TypeKey Profile Page] :

    "Compassionate Conservative" is an oxymoron. Come to think about it most Republicans are one kind of moron or another.
    The problem here is that there are some people, especially out on the eastern plains of Montana, where news doesn't seem to get around too good, who will probably believe the Republican lies.
    Of course, even those people pay attention to the fire news, since the mostly dry grass and sagebrush prairie fires can be as destructive to buildings, crops, and farm animals as the forest fires are in the western half of the state.
    A lot of people are getting pretty fed up with the antics of the tantrum-throwing screw-the-people Republicans.
    I'll bet the 2009 version of the state legislature will have significantly fewer Republicans in it than the current one.

    Posted on September 2, 2007 9:34 AM
  • TJ Colatrella [TypeKey Profile Page] :

    Republicans are Fascists, corporate theocratic hypocritical fascists..


    Republicans = Fascists..!

    Always and forever..!

    Simple as that..!


    Posted on September 2, 2007 9:51 AM
  • aardvark [TypeKey Profile Page] :

    Compassionate does not fit with Conservative in the case of these Neanderthal Thugs! There definitely will be less of them after the 2008 Montana elections.

    Posted on September 10, 2007 4:24 PM

Join the Discussion

Post a comment